Skip to main content

Free estimates

A-1 TrenchlessWater and Sewer Repair

Sewer Pipe Lining Reviews: An Honest Look at CIPP Liners

TrenchlessUpdated 5 min read

Search for sewer pipe lining reviews and you find two kinds of stories. Some homeowners say a liner saved their yard and fixed years of backups in a day. Others say they paid for a liner and had the same problem six months later. Both stories are usually true. The difference almost always comes down to whether the pipe was a good candidate for lining and how carefully the job was prepped.

This is our honest review of cured in place pipe lining, often called CIPP, written from the point of view of a sewer contractor who also does traditional digs and pipe bursting. We have no reason to push lining on a pipe that does not suit it, so here is what it does well and where it falls short.

What a sewer pipe liner actually is

A CIPP liner is a flexible tube, usually felt or fiberglass, soaked in resin. It goes into the existing sewer pipe through a cleanout or a small access point, gets pressed against the pipe wall, and hardens in place. Once it cures, you have a new seamless pipe inside the old one.

The old pipe stays in the ground and acts as a form. The liner does the work from then on.

What lining does well

It seals every joint at once. Clay and cast iron lines leak and let roots in at the joints. A liner runs past all of them with no seams, so roots have nowhere to enter. For root problems in an otherwise sound pipe, this is the strongest argument for lining.

It needs little or no digging. Most residential lining jobs use the existing cleanout plus, at most, one small access pit. That matters when the line runs under a driveway, a patio, a finished basement slab or mature trees you do not want to lose.

It is fast. A typical residential lateral is cleaned, lined and cured in a day or two. There is no long trench to backfill, settle and reseed.

It leaves a smooth inside surface. Scale, roots and rough joints are gone, so waste flows freely even though the liner adds a thin wall.

The result is easy to verify. A camera inspection after curing shows the finished liner from end to end. You can see exactly what you paid for.

Where lining falls short

It cannot fix a pipe that has lost its shape. If a section is crushed, collapsed or badly out of round, the liner has nothing to form against. This is the most common reason lining jobs fail, and it is why the camera inspection before the job matters more than anything else.

It does not fix a belly. A liner follows the old pipe exactly. If a section has sagged and holds standing water, it still sags after lining. That section usually needs a short open repair first.

Prep is everything. The pipe has to be cleaned down to the wall before the liner goes in. Heavy roots, grease or cast iron scale left behind can stop the liner from bonding and leave wrinkles or weak spots. Skipping or rushing the cleaning is where many bad lining reviews start.

It slightly reduces the inside diameter. On most residential sewer lines this does not affect flow, but on an already undersized line it is worth discussing.

It is not always the cheapest option. For one short broken section under open lawn, a simple spot repair can cost less than lining the whole line. Lining makes the most financial sense when digging would mean tearing up something expensive to replace.

Is your sewer line a good candidate for a liner?

Lining is usually a good fit when the camera shows:

  • cracks, open joints or root intrusion along the line
  • a pipe that is still round and continuous
  • no major sags or collapsed sections
  • a line under hardscape, a slab or landscaping you want to keep

Lining is usually a poor fit when the camera shows:

  • crushed or collapsed sections
  • a belly that holds water
  • severe offsets where one section has shifted well out of line
  • Orangeburg pipe that has deformed

When lining is not the right call, pipe bursting can often still replace the line without a full trench. Our guide to pipe bursting and pipe lining compares the two side by side.

How to read pipe lining reviews

When you read reviews of a lining company, or of lining in general, look past the star rating and ask:

  1. Did the company show the customer the camera footage before and after? Happy lining customers almost always saw the before and after video.
  2. Was the pipe cleaned first? Complaints about liners that failed early often trace back to a line that was not fully cleaned or descaled.
  3. Did the reviewer have a sag or collapse that lining could not fix? That is a diagnosis problem, not a liner problem.
  4. Does the company also dig and burst pipe? A contractor who only lines tends to line everything.

Questions we hear about sewer liners

How long does a CIPP liner last? A properly installed liner in a well prepared pipe is designed to last for decades. The biggest factors are the condition of the host pipe and the quality of the cleaning and installation.

Can a liner go through bends? Many systems handle the gentle bends found in residential laterals. Sharp fittings and changes in pipe size need to be checked on camera first.

What happens to the branch connections? Connections such as a second bathroom line are located on camera and reopened from the inside after the liner cures.

Can cast iron under a slab be lined? Often, yes, once the scale is removed. Badly corroded cast iron may first need pipe descaling, and pipe that has rotted through in places may need replacement instead.

Do I still need a camera inspection if I already know the pipe is bad? Yes. Knowing it is bad is not the same as knowing whether it can be lined. The inspection decides the method.

Our approach

A-1 Trenchless Services works on sewer and water lines across Montgomery, Prince George's, Howard and Frederick counties from our base in Damascus. Every job starts with a camera inspection that we show you, and we recommend the repair that fits what the camera finds, whether that is a liner, pipe bursting, a spot repair or a traditional dig.

If you want a straight answer on whether your line can be lined, request a free estimate or call (301) 254-8401.

First published . Written by the A-1 Trenchless team.

Water where it should not be?

Backups and broken lines get worse the longer water runs. Call us and tell us what you are seeing. We will tell you what to do right now and what it will take to fix it.

Monday to Friday, 8 AM to 5 PM. Free estimates on every job.

Call NowFree Quote